File #: ID 21-1997    Version: 1 Name:
Type: City Council Item Status: Agenda Ready
File created: 11/23/2021 In control: City Council
On agenda: 12/6/2021 Final action: 12/6/2021
Title: Appeal of Planning Board Decision (APBG-21-000256) - Boat Dock Extension Request (BD-21-000177) to Extend a Dock to Forty-Two-feet as shown on the plans for the property located at 986 Sundrop Court, Marco Island, FL 34145
Attachments: 1. Marco Island Quasi, 2. Marco Island Quasi Judicial Proceedings (FNL - 10-28-21), 3. Material submitted for Sept. 3, 2021 PB and updated staff report, 4. Staff Report, 5. Planning Board Resolution 21-46 Denial 986 Sundrop, 6. Planning Board 9-3-21 Minutes, 7. Application, Exhibits A-C, Attachments 1-2, 8. Letter of Objection - 980 Sundrop Court, 9. Addendum to Letter of Objections Signed with Exhibit A, 10. Letter of Objection - 983 Sundrop Court, 11. Letter of Objection E-mailed to Planning Board, 12. Objection to Boat Dock Extension Application, 13. Re: Public Notice to Adjacent Neighbors 15 days Prior to 9-3-21 - Mailing Return - NOT for Granicus, 14. Reply to Staff, 15. Applicant Appeal of Planning Board Denial for BD, 16. Applicant Appeal 11-19-21 Submittal, 17. Notice of Appeal, 18. Response in Opposition to McBride's Motion in Limine v2, 19. Signed Affidavit with Exhibits, 20. Objections and Support for Appeal of the Denial of BD, 21. Dr. Rajani Thangavelu-Notice of opposition, 22. McBride Opposition and Notice, 23. McBride Appellees motion in limine, 24. Espy Notices, 25. Glass-Bowman Notice of Affected Persons and appeal, 26. FW_ 986 Sundrop Court appeal -- OPPOSITION REASONING, 27. FW_ SUPERYACHT, 28. FW_ SUPPORT Petition BD-21-000177_ 986 Sundrop Ct Marco Island, 29. Petition BD-21-00177 966 Sundrop Court Marco Island_ FL PPEAL OF RESOLUTION 21-46 DENYING PETITION, 30. Petition-BD-21-000177_986_Sundrop_Court, 31. RE DOCK APPEAL_ Notice of Appeal to City Council and Appeal of Planning, 32. RE_ 986 Sundrop Court appeal -- OPPOSITION REASONING, 33. sundrop ct, 34. Support Petition BD-21-000177_ 986 Sundrop Court_ Marco Island_ FL, 35. Support Petition BD-21-000177_ 986 Sundrop Court_ Marco Island_ FL_ Appeal of Resolution 21-46 Denying Petition BD-21-000177, 36. SUPPORT Petition BD-21-000177_ 986 Sundrop Ct Marco Island
Agenda Item: 3
Prepared By: Daniel J. Smith, AICP, Director
Business: Appeal of Planning Board Decision
Department: Growth Management
Subject:
Title
Appeal of Planning Board Decision (APBG-21-000256) - Boat Dock Extension Request (BD-21-000177) to Extend a Dock to Forty-Two-feet as shown on the plans for the property located at 986 Sundrop Court, Marco Island, FL 34145
Body


BACKGROUND:

PROJECT DESCRIPTION

Mr. Zach Lombardo submitted a request, on behalf of 986 Sundrop, LLC, to extend a boat dock ten (10) feet beyond the allowed thirty (30) feet for a total of forty-two (42) feet at 986 Sundrop Court, Marco Island, pursuant to City of Marco Island Code Section 54-115, "Sec. 54-115. - Boat dock extensions, protrusion or encroachment into the riparian setback." Attached are the application, responses to the criteria, and plans for review and consideration.

On September 3, 2021, the City of Marco Island Planning Board considered the request, and held a public hearing. The Planning Board denied the request at that meeting. Following the Planning Board's action, Mr. Lombardo filed an appeal, on behalf of 986 Sundrop, LLC of the denial pursuant to City of Marco Island Code Section 38-41 that provides for any aggrieved party to appeal any final decision of the Planning Board to the City Council. The petition and supporting documentation submitted by Mr. Lombardo is provided to the City Council in their packet.

In addition to the documentation submitted by Mr. Lombardo, Mitchell McBride, Esq., representing Gary and Lorrain McBride, owners of 980 Sundrop Court submitted a brief in support of the Planning Board's action. Mr. McBride's submittal is also included in the City Council packet.

PLANNING BOARD SUMMARY AND ACTION

The Planning Board considered this request and held a public hearing at their September 3, 2021 meeting After Staff presented the request, the Planning Board discussed hurricane procedures for removing the boat, beam size of the b...

Click here for full text