Legislation Details

File #: ID 25-4084    Version: 1 Name:
Type: City Council Item Status: Failed
File created: 1/8/2025 In control: City Council
On agenda: 1/21/2025 Final action: 1/21/2025
Title: Selection of Candidate to Fill the City Council Vacancy - Joan Taylor, City Clerk
Attachments: 1. 1-21-25 Council Ballots Vacant City Council Seat, 2. Anthony Costantino, 3. Bryan Johnson, 4. Chris Ricci, 5. Dr. Chrissann Ruehle, 6. Daniel Byant, 7. David Crain, 8. David Leaser, 9. Dennis Bartolucci, 10. Edwin Johnson, 11. John Aguis, 12. Joseph Carosia, 13. Kristy Strickland, 14. Mario Curiale, 15. Martin Winter, 16. Michael Dowell, 17. Nanette Rivera, 18. Peter Barlome, 19. Ralph Rohena, 20. Reza Mahdavi, 21. Richard Schulte, 22. Ryan Sullivan, 23. Sheelah Yawitz, 24. Teri Sommerfeld, 25. Thomas Fontana

Agenda Item:  4(a)

Prepared By:  Joan Taylor, City Clerk

Business:  Discussion

Department:   Executive

Subject:

Title

Selection of Candidate to Fill the City Council Vacancy - Joan Taylor, City Clerk

Body                     

 

 

BACKGROUND: 

 

On May 16, 2024, Councilor Greg Folley announced his resignation from the Marco Island City Council effective November 5, 2024. 

 

Section 3.05(3) of the City Charter provides the following process for filling a council vacancy: “If the remainder of the unexpired term is 28 months or less, the remaining Council Members shall, within sixty (60) days following the occurrence of such vacancy, by majority vote of the Council Members, appoint a person to fill the vacancy for the remainder of the unexpired term.”

 

During November 18, 2024, City Council meeting, Council members agreed to fill the vacancy through an application process which included interviews by Council members with a vote for appointment.  Applications were accepted from November 6-22, 2024. 

 

At a Special City Council meeting on December 2, 2024, Councilors selected four finalists:  Daniel Bryant, David Leaser, Martin Winter, and Teri Sommerfeld. During the month of December, Councilors interviewed the four finalists. 

 

On January 6, 2025, Councilors made nominations among the finalists to fill the vacant position. None of the finalists received a majority vote and therefore, the vacancy was not filled. 

 

At today’s Special Called Meeting, Council members will discuss their recommendations for the candidate selection process and appoint the candidate.

 

Applications and resumes from all the interested candidates have been included for Council’s review (the two candidates who had previously withdrawn their applications continue to not be included).  Listed in alphabetical order by first name are the applicants and their resumes are attached:

 

Anthony Costantino

Joseph Carosia

Ryan Sullivan

Bryan Johnson

Kristy Strickland

Sheelah Yawitz

Chris Ricci

Mario Curiale

Teri Sommerfeld *

Dr. Chrissann Ruehle

Martin Winter *

Thomas Fontana

Daniel Bryant *

Michael Dowel

 

David Crain

Nanette Rivera

 

David Leaser *

Peter Bartlome

 

Dennis Bartolucci

Ralph Rohena

 

Edwin Johnson

Reza Mahdavi

 

John Aguis

Richard Schulte

 

 

* December 2nd finalists: Daniel Bryant, David Leaser, Martin Winter, and Teri Sommerfeld. 

 

 

 

FUNDING SOURCE / FISCAL IMPACT:  N / A

 

 

RECOMMENDATION:   Align on Council member vacancy selection process.  Appoint the candidate to fill the Council member vacancy.

 

 

POTENTIAL MOTION:  I move to appoint _____________________ to fill the City Council vacancy.